Wikipedia warns against French attempt to extend EU privacy law globally
Google appealed last month against an order from the French data protection authority to remove certain web search results globally.
A 2014 ruling by the European Court of Justice allowed people to ask the likes of Google or Microsoft’s Bing to remove inadequate or irrelevant information from web results brought up by searching for their name.
The measure, known as the “right to be forgotten”, has pitted privacy campaigners against defenders of free speech.
“One of the most disturbing things is the regulators in France have demanded that Google hide things globally, not just within the borders of France,” Wales told Reuters late on Thursday on the sidelines of the Brilliant Minds conference in Stockholm.
“That’s just opening a disastrous can of worms, because then it becomes a ridiculous race to the bottom, where the Internet is censored by the most restrictive jurisdictions,” he said.
“And nobody thinks we should censor based on the whims of the Chinese government, for example. But that’s the path that people go down if they are not careful.”
Google complied with France’s request, but it scrubbed results only across its European websites, arguing that to go further would set a dangerous precedent on the territorial reach of national laws.
Wales said Wikipedia was also working to adhere to the legislation.
The French data protection authority argues that a person’s right to privacy should not depend on where an online search is made, and counters allegations of censorship by noting that the links in question, hidden when a person’s name is searched for directly, can still be found by searching in different ways.
Wales said his staff at the Wikimedia Foundation, the non-profit organization that runs the online encyclopedia, assembled and written by Internet users around the world, were spending more and more time dealing with national regulations on the Internet.
“We’ve all become somehow kind of amateur lawyers on things like copyright,” he said.