It’s a somewhat disturbing fable, but is there truth behind the tale?
Some believe that the tale chronicles a real set of events that took place in Hamelin.
Long before the Brothers Grimm chronicled the fairy tale in their anthology of stories, curious writings regarding the piper story appeared.
For example, a document from 1384 about Hamelin’s history states that an unrelated event took place “…100 years since our children left.”
Dated to about 1440 C.E., another manuscript states: “In the year of 1284, on June 26…a piper, clothed in many kinds of colours, (there were) 130 children born in Hamelin were seduced, and lost at the place of execution near the hill.”
It is interesting to note that at no place in the above manuscripts is there any mention of rats. The rodents don’t get added into the story until Count von Zimmern’s 16th century “Zimmern Chronicle.”
Richard Rowland Verstegan wrote a book in 1605 that states that the children were not harmed, but emigrated to Transylvania.
Versions in later books consider the story to be merely a fairy tale and add whimsical bits such as some disabled children were spared because they were unable to keep up with the other children, who met their doom by being marched into a cave, never to be seen again.
So if the story is based in reality, what actually happened?
Some theorists of centuries past believe the piper was the devil and spirited the children away for his own nefarious purposes. More recent researchers believe the piper represents a plague that struck the town, claiming mainly children as its victims.
Others believe the story tells of a children’s religious crusade to Jerusalem that did not meet with success. And others believe the tale merely chronicles a large but sudden emigration (not only of children, but of adults as well) from Hamelin to other places in Europe.
Like many folktales, there may be a germ of truth in the Pied Piper story. Unfortunately, there is not enough evidence passed down through time to determine what actually happened in the small village of medieval Hamelin.
References
Historic Mysteries
“Was there really a pied piper of Hamelin?” howstuffworks.com website, pulled 21-Nov-12.
“The Pied Piper of Hameln” pitt.edu website, pulled 21-Nov-12.
“Pied Piper of Hamelin” Wikipedia, pulled 21-Nov-12.
Leave a Comment